027 The Best Design Ideas Often Begin as Mistakes

Some of the best ideas I've ever had didn't begin as ideas at all.

They began as problems.

Over the years I've learned that when something doesn't quite go according to plan, it isn't always asking to be hidden. Sometimes it's asking to become something better.

A One-Inch Problem

One day I was working on the front porch of Zehr Estate, installing decorative trim along the roofline.

I had completed one side, then moved to the opposite end where years of weather had left the structure in rough shape. After repairing the framing and continuing the trim, I eventually worked my way back toward the middle.

That's when I discovered the problem.

Somehow I was about an inch off.

One section was slightly lower than the other.

Everything was already securely nailed together. Taking it apart wasn't practical, and forcing it into alignment would likely create more problems than it solved.

So I climbed down from the lift, stepped back about ten feet, and simply looked at it.

Sometimes distance gives you better perspective than another hour of work.

Looking for a Different Question

My first thought was the same one most builders have.

How do I hide this?

But after standing there for a while, another question came to mind.

What if this could become a design feature instead?

I remembered making small decorative corner pieces for an old basement doorway years earlier. They had helped disguise a doorway that wasn't perfectly square while also adding character.

Maybe the same idea could work here.

Sleep Is Sometimes Part of the Design Process

I made one small decorative piece with 45-degree angles on each end and nailed it in place.

It worked.

The transition disappeared.

But more importantly...

...it actually looked better.

Instead of immediately making dozens more, I went home.

I thought about it that evening.

The next morning I walked into the workshop with a completely different plan.

I built enough pieces to continue the pattern across the entire porch.

Back on the lift I installed a few.

Then I backed the lift away.

I looked.

I smiled.

It belonged there.

Amy liked it too.

The Scallops

I call these little decorative pieces scallops.

They repeat along the roofline, adding rhythm, shadow, and visual interest without drawing attention to themselves.

Ironically, they only exist because something was one inch off.

That mistake became one of my favorite architectural details.

A Design Language Begins

Over the following weeks I found myself looking at other completed roofs around Zehr Estate.

I realized the scallops could help tie older sections and newer additions together.

So I went back and added them where they made sense.

Suddenly the buildings felt more unified.

Different generations of construction began speaking the same architectural language.

It no longer mattered which part had been built first.

They all belonged together.

Wood...and Aluminum

Most of the new construction uses traditional wooden scallops.

But another opportunity appeared while working on Zehr Escape.

My brother was dismantling an old building that had an aluminum roof.

I noticed the roofing wasn't steel—it was aluminum.

I asked if I could salvage it.

"Take it," he said. "You'll save me some work."

I remembered a roofing trick my uncle had taught me years earlier.

Using a utility knife, I scored the metal alongside each rib, bent it back and forth, and cleanly separated the flat sections.

By the end I had a large stack of usable ten-inch-wide aluminum.

Months later, while wondering how to add scallops beneath vinyl drip edge at Zehr Escape, the answer suddenly appeared.

I cut the aluminum into the same scallop pattern, slid each piece neatly under the drip edge, and fastened it in place.

It worked beautifully.

The originals received aluminum.

The additions received wood.

From the ground, they all work together.

The eye notices the design—not the material.

Lessons from an Uncle

One of my favorite things about building is realizing that knowledge never really disappears.

A simple roofing technique learned decades earlier from my uncle helped save material that eventually became an architectural detail on another building.

You never know which lesson will become useful years later.

Looking Beyond the Mistake

I've come to believe that many mistakes aren't asking to be covered up.

They're asking us to slow down.

To step back.

To ask a better question.

Instead of saying, "How do I hide this?", try asking, "Is there a better design hiding inside this problem?"

Sometimes the answer changes more than the project.

Sometimes it changes the way you build forever.

---

Wood Artistry Lesson: Experience teaches us how to solve problems. Creativity teaches us how to transform them. Many of the details we admire most didn't begin as part of the plan—they became part of the design because someone was willing to see an opportunity where others only saw a mistake.